I've always valued friendships where we can be honest with one another, where we can disagree, ask difficult questions, and still know that the love and respect between us isn't going anywhere. But I've also learned that being open to that kind of honesty means being willing to take a hard look at yourself sometimes.
My friend Melissa recently gave me one of those moments, and I've been thinking about our conversation ever since.
We were discussing a video that had gone viral during Abdul El-Sayed's campaign for the U.S. Senate in Michigan. El-Sayed, who has since won the election and made history as the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate, was speaking at a town hall when a man asked whether he would disavow the Muslim Brotherhood.
El-Sayed answered yes, but rather than leaving it there, he challenged the man about why he felt the need to ask that question in the first place.
When I watched the exchange, I found myself wishing he had responded differently. He was direct and firm, and although I didn't think he was rude, I was uncomfortable with how confrontational the exchange had become.
I've always believed in building bridges, finding common ground, and treating people with respect, even when we disagree. So I wondered whether he might have been more effective simply answering the question and moving on.
When I shared my thoughts with Melissa, she offered a perspective I hadn't considered. She wondered whether my reaction might have more to do with my own privilege than with anything El-Sayed had done.
At first, I wasn't sure what to make of that. But as we talked, I began to understand what she meant.
Why was I so focused on how El-Sayed responded rather than on the question he had been asked? Here was a man being put in a position where he was expected to defend his faith and, implicitly, his loyalty to his country. Would someone have asked a Christian candidate the same question? And why was I expecting him to make that moment more comfortable for everyone else?
I had been looking at the exchange through the lens of my own experiences, without fully considering his.
That was difficult to recognize, but Melissa was right to ask me to think about it.
The truth is, I've had the privilege of moving through much of my life without regularly having to defend my faith, my identity, or my right to belong. I've rarely had to consider what it would feel like to have someone question my character simply because of who I am. And because of that, I've often had the freedom to choose when to engage in difficult conversations and when to walk away.
It's much easier to encourage someone to take the high road when you're not the person being questioned.
As I've reflected on this, I've also started thinking about the times in my own life when I've chosen to stay quiet. I've spent years advocating for human dignity, equality, and bringing people together. Those values are deeply important to me, and I genuinely believe that compassion and listening can help us better understand one another.
But I can also think of moments when I've heard something that troubled me and didn't say anything. Sometimes I didn't want to create tension. Other times I convinced myself that keeping the peace was more important than challenging a comment or an assumption.
I don't believe those choices came from a lack of caring. But I'm beginning to recognize that good intentions don't always mean we're doing what the moment asks of us.
I think about the immigrant families I've come to know and love, and the uncertainty and fear many are experiencing. I think about people in our communities who find themselves having to defend their place in a country they call home. These aren't abstract issues to me. They affect people with families, hopes, responsibilities, and lives that matter just as much as my own.
And I have to ask myself whether caring about them privately is enough. When I hear harmful assumptions being made about immigrants, about people of different faiths, or about who belongs, am I willing to speak up? Or do I sometimes let those moments pass because I don't want to make anyone uncomfortable?
That's something I'm still working through.
I haven't stopped believing in the importance of building bridges. If anything, I believe in it more than ever. I want to continue listening to people whose experiences and perspectives are different from mine, and I want to approach those conversations with kindness and an open heart.
But Melissa helped me understand that building bridges doesn't always mean avoiding conflict. Sometimes it means being willing to have a difficult conversation because we care enough about one another, and about the people affected, not to look away.
I also see El-Sayed's response differently now. What I initially interpreted as confrontational may have been an important moment of standing up for himself and challenging an assumption that affects many others who share his faith.
I don't know that every difficult conversation calls for the same response, and I'm certainly not suggesting that I have the answers. I'm still learning when to listen, when to ask questions, and when I need to be more courageous about speaking up.
I hope I never stop being someone who believes in kindness, compassion, and bringing people together. But I also hope I continue growing into someone who understands that those values sometimes require more of me than simply keeping the peace.
And I'm grateful for the friends who love me enough to remind me of that.

